September 7, 2013

Dragonfly in mud a canary in coal mine for our times

‘In order for us to understand us, we need to look at other species,’ says Maine scientist

By North Cairn
Staff Writer

Working in Acadia National Park one recent morning, Sarah Nelson, a biological geochemist at the University of Maine, stood with her five assistants in boots and waders and jabbed at the sediment on the bottom of Hodgdon and Seal Cove ponds with long-handled nets.

click image to enlarge

Chad Coffin, a Freeport clam digger, holds handfuls of green crabs while looking for the invasive species off the coast of Freeport in May.

Portland Press Herald photo by Gabe Souza

Their target was dragonfly larvae, and the samples they took to a laboratory on campus would be identified, analyzed and finally incinerated.

In the ash they would measure concentrations of mercury, a toxic heavy metal that can wreak havoc on the environment and human health.

For researchers such as Nelson, the dragonfly is not just an elegant insect with a voracious appetite for mosquito larvae. It’s also a “sentinel” species, a stand-in for humans that provides clues to potentially harmful environmental conditions we otherwise might not notice.

Fifty years have passed since Rachel Carson first coined the term, but as human effects on the planet multiply, scientists say it’s still a critical concept for understanding changes in the environment.

“Long-term ecological research (on sentinel species) is absolutely required,” said H. Bruce Rinker, director of scientific advancement at the Biodiversity Research Institute in Gorham. “In order for us to understand us, we need to look at other species.”

The study of sentinel species goes back a long time, arguably to ancient times when the art of augury was practiced. By examining the entrails of certain animals, it was thought, the fate of emperors or the outcomes of battles could be predicted.

The classic sentinel species — at least in America — harks back to the mines of the 19th century. The canary in the coal mine — once employed to describe the process of releasing a small yellow bird into mine shafts to gauge air quality and the safety of miners — has become a linguistic fixture to illustrate how the fate of one species may portend the circumstances faced by others.

A miner who watched a canary flutter off and fall or head into a tunnel without returning knew not to enter the darkness himself. If the level of toxic gases — usually, carbon monoxide — could kill a bird, the theory held, they could hurt a man, too, or even kill.

“When the canary can no longer breathe, (it’s) a harbinger of human death, said Patrick Keenan, outreach director at the Gorham institute.

Over time, as scientific investigation has evolved, the canary has been joined by many other species that are monitored for an increasing number and range of reasons, including predicting humans’ safety.

Scientists from state agencies, academic institutions and research laboratories in Maine are studying tiny copepods, certain fish species and larger crustaceans in the ocean; freshwater fish and migratory birds in ponds; loons on inland lakes; and moose and bears in the North Woods.

Researchers say many of these studies start on a shoestring and run long-term, their modest funding bolstered by a robust commitment of time and energy from students and volunteer citizen-scientists.
The years of monitoring, data collection and scientific inquiry in Maine have begun to pay off in hard facts and sobering realities:

• Mercury has spread almost everywhere, sparking international debate and multinational treaties dealing with the pollution.

• Lead, once the poster poison of children in older buildings in inner cities, is still the leading cause of death in adult loons, claiming more than one-third of North American loon populations.

• Plastic waste, which is virtually indestructible, has become a commonplace pollutant in oceans all over the planet.

• Creatures that span the ecological chasms between very different ecosystems are in peril from human-induced climate change and its ripple effect on the water column and food web of the seas.
Nelson, the UMaine professor studying dragonflies, doesn’t need a lot of high-tech equipment to do sentinel species work. The critical tools are waders, nets, plastic sample bags, hand lenses and field guides.

(Continued on page 2)

Were you interviewed for this story? If so, please fill out our accuracy form

Send question/comment to the editors

Further Discussion

Here at we value our readers and are committed to growing our community by encouraging you to add to the discussion. To ensure conscientious dialogue we have implemented a strict no-bullying policy. To participate, you must follow our Terms of Use.

Questions about the article? Add them below and we’ll try to answer them or do a follow-up post as soon as we can. Technical problems? Email them to us with an exact description of the problem. Make sure to include:
  • Type of computer or mobile device your are using
  • Exact operating system and browser you are viewing the site on (TIP: You can easily determine your operating system here.)