February 4, 2013

Health risk from CMP's smart meters low, study finds

The results, however, provide little comfort to people who complain that the meters are hurting their health.

By Tux Turkel tturkel@pressherald.com
Staff Writer

An independent study of radio-frequency emissions from Central Maine Power Co.'s new smart meters has found maximum exposure levels that are far below what the Federal Communications Commission considers safe.

click image to enlarge

In this file photo, a Central Maine Power smart meter displays electricity usage at a business in Freeport in late 2010. An independent study of radio-frequency emissions from CMP's smart meters has found maximum exposure levels that are far below what the Federal Communications Commission considers safe.


Related Documents

Radio frequency exposure report for the Office of the Maine Public Advocate

The study, reviewed Monday by the Portland Press Herald, concluded that the highest exposure level averaged over time is 4.6 percent of the FCC limit. The agency regulates equipment that broadcasts radio-frequency signals.

The report was done by True North Associates and C2 Systems and overseen by Maine's Office of the Public Advocate.

The results, however, provide little comfort to people who complain that the meters are hurting their health, causing symptoms that include headaches and fatigue. They say the findings were expected and are meaningless.

"The question is, are there biological effects at levels lower than the FCC guidelines?" said Ed Friedman, the Bowdoinham man who led a court suit last year on behalf of smart-meter opponents. "Our evidence submitted proves that beyond a shadow of a doubt."

Friedman said the testimony he has received from international experts and a survey of affected people will document health effects from smart meters. That evidence has been submitted to the Maine Public Utilities Commission, for an ongoing case meant to resolve health and safety questions about the new meters.

But to CMP, the study confirms the utility's position that smart meters are safe and that opponents actually have a wider target that includes all wireless technology, including baby monitors and garage door openers.

"This is not a case about smart meters," said John Carroll, a CMP spokesman. "It's a case about people who think radio waves and radio technology are making them sick."

The study is part of a case that's slowly progressing at the PUC. In 2010, regulators approved plans for CMP to replace old-style analog electric meters for its 615,000 customers with digital smart meters. The $200 million project received half of its funding from federal stimulus dollars.

The commission thought it had addressed health and safety questions at the time, when the issue was first raised. But last summer, the Maine Supreme Judicial Court sided with opponents of the new-technology meters, who argued that regulators ignored their legal mandate to ensure the delivery of "safe, reasonable and adequate" utility service.

Two weeks later, commissioners voted to investigate the wireless devices.

CMP argued that the scope of the review should be narrow and focused on the legal requirement. But opponents succeeded in pushing for a fully litigated case, which involves reams of written and oral testimony from expert witnesses and aggrieved residents, rebuttals and discovery, hearings and, finally, deliberations.

Those hearings have been set for May, with deliberations later this year.

Informing their decision will be the hiring by Richard Davies, the state's public advocate, of an independent expert to test the levels of radio-frequency output at actual homes.

"There's a sense that opponents don't trust CMP to give them the facts," Davies said.

The study was conducted in January, in Portland and Augusta. It was done over a series of days in three homes. Consultants also measured emissions from other parts of the network that relay data into the customer billing and information systems. The specific locations and dates weren't disclosed to CMP.

Many utilities around the world are moving to smart meters, which can give customers online information about their energy-use patterns and allow power companies to pinpoint problems during outages. The meters also transmit usage data to the utilities, virtually eliminating the need for meter readers.

(Continued on page 2)

Were you interviewed for this story? If so, please fill out our accuracy form

Send question/comment to the editors

Further Discussion

Here at OnlineSentinel.com we value our readers and are committed to growing our community by encouraging you to add to the discussion. To ensure conscientious dialogue we have implemented a strict no-bullying policy. To participate, you must follow our Terms of Use.

Questions about the article? Add them below and we’ll try to answer them or do a follow-up post as soon as we can. Technical problems? Email them to us with an exact description of the problem. Make sure to include:
  • Type of computer or mobile device your are using
  • Exact operating system and browser you are viewing the site on (TIP: You can easily determine your operating system here.)