October 15, 2012

TRUTH TEST: Anti same-sex marriage ad is barely true

By Michael Shepherd mshepherd@centralmaine.com
Staff Writer

Protect Marriage Maine, the coalition opposing same-sex marriage, bases an ad in part on an interpretation of a state law passed in 2004 to allow gay couples to register as domestic partners. The ad says the law allowed rights that married couples have in "virtually all" circumstances.

ABOUT TRUTH TEST
Truth Test is a feature of MaineToday Media’s campaign coverage, in which we cast a critical eye on the truthfulness of advertising and public comments by political candidates and groups.

"Virtually all" should come with a pretty high standard. Maine law does allow for protections in some circumstances, but there are many cases in which it doesn't.

The anti-gay marriage coalition hasn't fared well so far in Truth Tests, getting two falses earlier this year for claims made on its website using bad information on child-rearing studies and saying tax-exempt status could be at risk if gay marriage passes. This claim is a little more true, but barely.

"Same-sex couples already have the legal protections of marriage in virtually all circumstances."

We reached out to the Maine Legislative and Law Library, and an employee there sent a 2009 fact document from Gay and Lesbian Advocates and Defenders, or GLAD, which compares Maine's domestic partnership protections with those of marriage.

The 2004 domestic partnership law does three main things, according to GLAD's website: It gives partners inheritance rights in the absence of a will, gives the surviving partner next-of-kin rights when determining end-of-life arrangements for the deceased partner, and gives a partner priority as guardians or conservators when a partner is disabled.

To get that, however, same-sex couples would have to meet some criteria that married folks don't. Both partners must have lived in Maine for 12 months, the law says. That, and some other things, show the law is not nearly as strong as a marriage.

Let's start with what domestic partners are promised under other pieces of law before we get to what they aren't.

A 2007 Maine Supreme Judicial Court interpretation of state law says same-sex couples can adopt children jointly. Another law says private health insurers must offer policies for domestic partners "under the same terms and conditions" as they offer them to married partners. Maine law also says: "An adult who shares an emotional, physical and financial relationship with the patient similar to that of a spouse" also can act as a surrogate for a partner in health care situations.

GLAD's website says that in Maine custody struggles, if a nonbirth or non-adoptive parent participates overwhelmingly in the parenting process, "he or she is entitled to be considered for an award of full parental rights and responsibilities." That would suggest same-sex parents would be eligible.

The Legislature also has amended other pieces of law to accommodate same-sex couples, including the Family Medical Leave Act, domestic-violence laws and access to partners' absentee ballots.

But that's not all marriage is legally about. There are some significant ways in which the 2004 domestic partnership law doesn't come close to measuring up with marriage.

Among GLAD's list of 10 protections of marriage that aren't afforded to same-sex couples, some are minor and some aren't; but it shows that references to domestic couples aren't made in many parts of Maine law.

Some pieces refer to federal benefits, such as Social Security. We'll ignore those for this check, because the federal Defense of Marriage Act prohibits the recognition of state-sanctioned same-sex relationships even if Maine calls one marriage. We're focused on pieces of state law.

For example, GLAD says that although domestic partners can go on their partner's health insurance, the originally insured person has to pay income tax on the value of their partner's piece of the policy. Spouses don't.

The document also notes difficulty at ending relationships. Divorces are necessarily available only to spouses, and GLAD calls the processes to end domestic partnerships "unpredictable" given that they fail to provide protections available under a divorce.

(Continued on page 2)

Were you interviewed for this story? If so, please fill out our accuracy form

Send question/comment to the editors




Further Discussion

Here at OnlineSentinel.com we value our readers and are committed to growing our community by encouraging you to add to the discussion. To ensure conscientious dialogue we have implemented a strict no-bullying policy. To participate, you must follow our Terms of Use.

Questions about the article? Add them below and we’ll try to answer them or do a follow-up post as soon as we can. Technical problems? Email them to us with an exact description of the problem. Make sure to include:
  • Type of computer or mobile device your are using
  • Exact operating system and browser you are viewing the site on (TIP: You can easily determine your operating system here.)