October 7, 2012

Jay Mercier trial: How police cracked Maine's oldest cold case

By Doug Harlow dharlow@centralmaine.com
Staff Writer

SKOWHEGAN -- When physical evidence in the 32-year-old murder case against Jay Mercier seemed to bog down in court last month with tire tracks and old photographs, the state still had one trick left up its prosecutorial sleeve: DNA.

click image to enlarge

Jay Mercier sits emotionless as a jury of his peers return from deliberations with the verdict of guilty in the murder of Rita St. Peter at Somerset County Superior Court in Skowhegan in this Sept. 24 file photo.

Staff file photo by Michael G. Seamans

Investigative work by Maine State Police Detective Bryant Jacques, who collected biological samples from Mercier, and scientists at the State Police Crime Lab in Augusta who analyzed them, allowed prosecutors to convict Mercier of the brutal murder of 20-year-old Rita St. Peter in July 1980.

It was the state's oldest cold-case homicide.

Even so, it's not that rare anymore to get a guilty verdict by a jury in such an old case, says Assistant Attorney General William Stokes.

"It's not really that unusual," Stokes said. "We're finding increasing success in some of these old cases."

Even back in the 1980s, investigators took fluid samples from rape and murder victims. Samples from St. Peter's body were taken and stored during a time when no one ever heard of DNA.

Those samples were enough to send Mercier, 57, of Industry, to prison for 25 years to life. He will be sentenced next month.

"It's a very satisfying feeling to be able to go to the family of murder victims and to tell them we've had a break in the case," Stokes said. "It's something that they probably never expected; in some instances they've just given up hope."

Stokes points to the murder trial of Albert Cochran in 1999 when the attorney general's office used DNA samples taken from murder victim Janet Baxter in 1976 to get a conviction.

"That was unsolved for almost 23 years," he said.

There was the case against Thomas Mitchell Jr., who was indicted in September 2006 in the 1983 stabbing death of 23-year-old Judith Flagg in her Fayette home. Like Mercier, Mitchell had been a prime suspect for some time.

DNA found under Flagg's fingernails was linked to Mitchell. After a jury convicted him, he was sentenced in August 2009 to life in prison without parole.

Walt McKee, an Augusta attorney on the board of the Maine Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, says DNA evidence can work both ways -- it also can clear a suspect of criminal charges.

"I tried a case in Hancock County a couple of years ago where the DNA evidence was really important," McKee said. "It was obtained, it came back and it was not my client's DNA. In fact, no DNA was found, which in the context of that case was crucial and he was found not guilty."

McKee said DNA evidence in criminal cases changes the game for defense lawyers and how they represent a client. He said it requires lawyers to gain expertise in areas of biological and medical science that most trial lawyers do not have.

"Evidence collection becomes that much more critical, because of the risk of cross contamination," he said. "It requires a lot more preparation and it certainly has increased the cost of defending a major case where DNA is involved because of the cost of a DNA expert for the defense to at least review the evidence."

Maine went online with its first DNA laboratory in August 1997, replacing the science of serology, examining serums and human tissue fluids under a microscope, hoping comparisons with other samples would stand up in court.

Without the genetic profile of DNA, they often didn't.

Stokes said the attorney general's office now has a cold case prosecutor, Assistant Attorney General Laura Nomani, and all she does is work on unsolved case files. Nomani worked with Assistant Attorney General Andrew Benson in prosecuting Jay Mercier.

(Continued on page 2)

Were you interviewed for this story? If so, please fill out our accuracy form

Send question/comment to the editors




Further Discussion

Here at OnlineSentinel.com we value our readers and are committed to growing our community by encouraging you to add to the discussion. To ensure conscientious dialogue we have implemented a strict no-bullying policy. To participate, you must follow our Terms of Use.

Questions about the article? Add them below and we’ll try to answer them or do a follow-up post as soon as we can. Technical problems? Email them to us with an exact description of the problem. Make sure to include:
  • Type of computer or mobile device your are using
  • Exact operating system and browser you are viewing the site on (TIP: You can easily determine your operating system here.)