Maine residents slashed their heating oil use by 45 percent between 2004 and 2009, a dramatic reduction that’s highlighting the combined power of rising prices, stepped-up weatherization and new heating technologies.

Maine households cut heating oil use by a higher percentage than any New England state, figures from the U.S. Energy Information Administration show.

Additional Photos

Mark Mowatt, of Portland, has cut his oil use in half with a big weatherization effort on his Bradley Street home. Mowatt had foam insulation blown in along the sill of his basement. Maine Sunday Telegram photo by John Ewing

Maine remains more dependent on heating oil than any other state in the nation, causing a drain on the economy and on household budgets during a period of record-high prices. The number of Maine homes warmed primarily with oil still hovers in the 70 percent range, according to the latest U.S. Census data, down from 80 percent in 2000.

However, this statistical dependence belies just how much the state has weaned itself from oil heat in recent years. It’s an accomplishment that the director of Maine’s energy office says isn’t widely recognized, but is significant. The fact that a household retains an oil furnace as a central heating system, he said, doesn’t necessarily mean the unit is running all the time.

“The thing that counts is how much oil they’re using,” said Ken Fletcher. “That’s the bottom line.”

Several factors are at play in keeping oil furnaces from switching on as frequently, Fletcher and others say.

* Fuel switching: Roughly one in 10 Maine homes heat primarily with cordwood or wood pellets, increasingly with a new generation of cleaner-burning stoves and boilers. More homeowners also are converting to propane and, where it’s available, natural gas.

* Insulation: Whole-house weatherization that includes air sealing and heavy insulation can cut heat use by 40 percent. Even lesser measures add up.

* Efficient burners: Modern oil boilers can consume 10 percent to 40 percent fewer gallons than older models. That helps households that stay with oil.

* Economy: The recession and ongoing job slump have households cutting back on many fronts. That includes lowering the thermostat and closing off rooms.

These and other reactions are driven primarily by fuel oil prices, which have been volatile in recent years. The federal EIA is projecting record-high average prices this winter, up 10 percent from last year. Maine’s statewide average last week was $3.59 a gallon, reflecting a steady rise since the the heating season began.

The reaction to rising prices is being seen across New England and is reflected in regional statistics in the EIA data.

Total heating oil consumption in the six states fell 26 percent, from 4.5 billion gallons in 2004, to 3.4 billion gallons in 2009, the most recent year available. Households led the trend, with consumption down 34 percent during the period.

On a state-by-state basis, Maine cut oil use the most, by 45 percent. It was followed by New Hampshire, 39 percent; Connecticut, 29 percent; Massachusetts, 28 percent; Vermont, 27 percent; and Rhode Island, 25 percent.

Behind the drop are thousands of individual decisions.

A decade ago, the typical Maine home burned 1,000 gallons a year. The trade group representing oil dealers estimates average consumption is down to 850 gallons today, but the latest figures suggest that number may be too high.

“Dealers know their average has gone down,” said Jamie Py, executive director of the Maine Energy Marketers Association.

Oil dealers are reacting to the shift. Many sell propane; others are diversifying into wood pellets and solar panels. They all encourage conservation and efficiency, he said, as a way to retain customers.

Mark Mowatt’s house is one example of how individual actions cut consumption.

Located in Portland, Mowatt’s 90-year old home was so leaky he could feel a breeze blowing inside with the doors and windows shut. A year ago, he signed up for a whole-house weatherization program administered by Efficiency Maine.

Following a professional energy audit, Mowatt had the walls and attic insulated, the rim joist sealed and a new furnace installed. The project cost $10,000, but oil consumption dropped in half last winter, to less than 400 gallons. Comfort is an added bonus.

“Otherwise,” he said, “we’d still be sitting here with jackets on in the fall, trying to stay warm.”

In an older home with few energy improvements, cutting oil consumption is easy. Officials know it’s more challenging to accomplish further, deep reductions across Maine’s broader housing stock.

The federal EIA winter heating forecast is projecting that consumption in the Northeast will fall by 1 percent, based simply on rising prices. Fletcher believes it’s possible for Maine to do more, and trim overall heating oil consumption by 5 percent a year.

“The technology is there and people are motivated,” he said.

Some of that motivation could be tempered, though, by the expiration of government incentives that helped pay for the upgrades done at Mowatt’s house.

Rebates are used up for Efficiency Maine’s home energy savings program, but the effort reached 3,200 households. They spent an average of $8,800 per home and cut energy use an average of 40 percent. The agency now is encouraging residents to pursue so-called PACE loans, which are tied to the upgraded property. Despite rising oil prices, many Mainers still live in old homes with few energy improvements, according to Dana Fischer, residential program manager at Efficiency Maine.

“We have barely scratched the surface,” he said. “There are thousands of homes out there with no insulation at all.”

Average statewide price for a gallon of home heating oil:

2010-11: $3.214

2009-10: $2.742

2008-09: $2.516

2007-08: $3.213

2006-07: $2.373

2005-06: $2.358

2004-05: $1.927

Prices are for the heating season of October through March

Source: Maine Office of Energy Independence and Security

Related Stories