July 3, 2013

Legal feast: Who owns fired Maine baker's recipes?

A baker fired by Micucci's says he owns the secrets to popular creations like luna bread, but the law is tricky.

By Meredith Goad mgoad@pressherald.com
Staff Writer

PORTLAND – It's unlikely that Stephen Lanzalotta's recipes are protected by copyright laws, experts say, but the instructions for his luna bread and Sicilian Slab pizza may include trade secrets that will make it difficult for Micucci Grocery, which fired him last week, to keep using them.

click image to enlarge

Customers leave Micucci's Grocery with their pizza slabs Monday. The grocery is still selling the slabs, luna bread and Italian pastries after baker Stephen Lanzalotta's departure.

John Ewing / Staff Photographer

click image to enlarge

Micucci's Grocery on India Street in Portland is well known for the Sicilian Slab pizza developed by fired baker Stephen Lanzalotta.

John Ewing / Staff Photographer

Attorneys who specialize in copyright and intellectual-property issues said they have not reviewed Lanzalotta's recipes or interviewed anyone involved in the case, so they can only speculate how the law would apply. But they can say one thing for certain: This is a confusing case with a "strange fact pattern" that leaves lots of room for interpretation.

Lanzalotta's firing from the popular Italian grocery on India Street raised some tasty legal questions: Can Micucci keep serving Lanzalotta's creations, or does he hold the rights to his recipes? Was an oral agreement that the recipes are his adequate, or should everything have been put in writing?

Recipes fall into a gray area of copyright law, in which some parts may be protected but others are not. If recipes are created for an employer, things get even trickier. There's also the question of whether the recipes contain elements that could be considered trade secrets.

"You'd like for it to be a nice, simple answer," said Charles P. Bacall, a partner in the Portland law firm Verrill Dana who specializes in copyright law and intellectual property rights, "but then all lawyers would be out of business."

The basic ingredients of recipe copyright law can be found in the U.S. Copyright Office in Washington, D.C., which says recipes that are "mere listings of ingredients" are not protected. That includes, apparently, the methods outlined for carrying out that recipe.

Copyright protection may be extended to recipes or collections of recipes (think cookbooks) that include "substantial literary expression" in the form of a description or explanation.

"What copyright really covers is creative expression," Bacall said. "So a novel, obviously, is covered by copyright law -- a statue, painting, a song, things like that. But the flip side of it is, it doesn't protect the ideas that are expressed in that novel or song."

That's why recipes are so tricky, Bacall said. Take, for example, a recipe for cooking a steak on a grill. The idea of seasoning a steak with salt and pepper and throwing it on the grill and cooking it for five minutes on each side is not protected.

"But if you were to write it up in flowery language and talk about how it brings back memories of your father on warm summer evenings tossing the baseball around or whatever, all that stuff would be protectable," Bacall said. That's because such language would be considered "original expression."

What if you wrote that little essay while working for someone else?

A second important component of copyright law is the "work for hire doctrine," which says works created by employees within the scope of their employment automatically belong to the employer -- absent some written agreement to the contrary.

So, for example, if you're hired to write poetry for a greeting card company, any poem you write will belong to the company.

Lanzalotta's case is complicated. He created his luna bread at the bakery he once owned, Sophia's. When he was hired by Micucci, he took the luna dough and added sauce and cheese, which means he created the Sicilian Slab, as his pizza is known, under Micucci's roof.

"I coined the name of Slab," Lanzalotta said, "brought the dough recipe from Sophia's, and presently hold the federal service trademark for 'Sicilian Slab.'"

The fact that the luna bread came from Sophia's "obviously doesn't work in the favor of (Micucci)," Bacall said.

(Continued on page 2)

Were you interviewed for this story? If so, please fill out our accuracy form

Send question/comment to the editors

Further Discussion

Here at OnlineSentinel.com we value our readers and are committed to growing our community by encouraging you to add to the discussion. To ensure conscientious dialogue we have implemented a strict no-bullying policy. To participate, you must follow our Terms of Use.

Questions about the article? Add them below and we’ll try to answer them or do a follow-up post as soon as we can. Technical problems? Email them to us with an exact description of the problem. Make sure to include:
  • Type of computer or mobile device your are using
  • Exact operating system and browser you are viewing the site on (TIP: You can easily determine your operating system here.)