January 13, 2013

COMMENTARY: The many what-ifs of Nixon's life

Bill Whalen

A century ago on Jan. 9, Richard Nixon was born in a Southern California agricultural subdivision dubbed Yorba Linda, in a 900-square-foot mail-order house assembled by his father.

 The centennial of America's 37th president won't be met with much fanfare beyond this weekend's wreath-laying at that home and a Nixon Foundation dinner Wednesday in Washington. Although the Nixon Library has other centennial-related events planned for 2013, there's little of the hoopla that accompanied the 100th birthday of California's other president, Ronald Reagan, two years ago.

 Like another former Republican president, Nixon is a victim of unfortunate political timing. Herbert Hoover's centennial, in 1974, came just two days after Nixon resigned from the presidency. Nixon's centennial comes two months after a bad election for Republicans, and his party is not exactly in a celebratory mood. By contrast, the ever-lucky Reagan's centennial came on the heels of the Republican landslide of 2010.

Still, Nixon's milestone is worth noting, beginning with his contributions to the political lexicon. How many times have we referenced a cornered candidate in need of a "Checkers speech," an unorthodox maneuver as a "Nixon goes to China" moment or the unfortunate tendency to affix "gate" to slightest whiff of scandal (more than 120 times, per Wikipedia's count)?

 It is also worth noting how history might have changed for three other presidents if not for three of Nixon's biggest political setbacks.

If Nixon had beaten John F. Kennedy in 1960: Change the outcomes in Illinois and Texas (Nixon lost the two states by 0.18 percent and 2 percent, respectively), and there would have been no "New Frontier," no tragedy in Dallas -- perhaps no enduring Camelot mystique. Kennedy might have opted for a rematch in 1964, or waited until 1968 (he'd have been only 51 then). Perhaps he would have chosen not to run again, and the Kennedy clan would be just another congressional dynasty.

If Nixon had won the California gubernatorial election in 1962: For starters, there would have been no bitter farewell ("You won't have Nixon to kick around anymore ..."). Would there have been a Gov. or President Ronald Reagan? Reagan's first gubernatorial run, in 1966, was made possible by two factors: an incumbent who served as progressive straw man (Pat Brown, who beat Nixon in 1962) to blame for social unrest and a state GOP lacking a colossus candidate.

Supposing Nixon had been re-elected to a second gubernatorial term in 1966 before capturing the presidency in 1968. Reagan might have run in California at a future date. But there might not have been the same fuel for the conservative fire then.

If there had been no Watergate: For openers, Fred Thompson probably wouldn't be peddling reverse mortgages on cable television today (the former senator from Tennessee cut his teeth in Washington as the Senate Watergate Committee's chief minority counsel).

Nor would the House Judiciary Committee have needed the services of a recent Yale Law graduate, Hillary Rodham, for its impeachment inquiry staff.

As for her future husband, consider how his presidency would differ if Watergate hadn't spawned 1978's Ethics in Government Act, which would later empower Kenneth Starr to pursue Bill Clinton's public and private lives. Thanks to that Nixonian reform, Clinton's own centennial observance, 33 years from now, will be more complicated than it might have been otherwise.

As to Nixon's personal what-if's, the possibilities are just as interesting. Here are a few examples.

(Continued on page 2)

Were you interviewed for this story? If so, please fill out our accuracy form

Send question/comment to the editors




Further Discussion

Here at OnlineSentinel.com we value our readers and are committed to growing our community by encouraging you to add to the discussion. To ensure conscientious dialogue we have implemented a strict no-bullying policy. To participate, you must follow our Terms of Use.

Questions about the article? Add them below and we’ll try to answer them or do a follow-up post as soon as we can. Technical problems? Email them to us with an exact description of the problem. Make sure to include:
  • Type of computer or mobile device your are using
  • Exact operating system and browser you are viewing the site on (TIP: You can easily determine your operating system here.)